Image

Root Canal vs. Tooth Extraction in Chicago: Dr. Bhagat’s Recommendation

By Wicker Park Dental Group | November 3, 2025

One of the major decisions you’ll have to make while dealing with a decayed or damaged tooth is between a root canal and the extraction of the tooth. While either treatment can save or address an ailing tooth, the best course for your dental health depends on numerous factors. Dr. Bhagat of Wicker Park Dental Group realizes how important being well-informed about your options is; so, here’s an honest guide to help you decide.

What Is a Root Canal?

A root canal is a procedure to save an infected or deeply decayed tooth. It involves the removal of infected tissue inside the tooth, cleaning the area, and sealing it to prevent future infections. Afterward, the tooth is usually restored with a crown to make sure it’s functional and natural-looking.

Why Choose a Root Canal?

  • Preserves your natural tooth: The root canal, therefore, lets you retain your tooth; it is always better to retain one’s teeth where possible.
  • Prevents further pain: This procedure removes infection, relieving the discomfort of the decay.
  • Functionality: The treated tooth, once healed, can last for many years with good care.

What is tooth extraction?

Extraction involves the complete removal of a damaged or decayed tooth from the mouth. This might sound extreme, but at times, it is necessary to extract teeth that cannot otherwise be saved. Often, extraction is recommended for teeth that are beyond repair or for troublesome wisdom teeth.

Why Choose Tooth Extraction?

  • Severe damage: If the tooth is too decayed or broken to restore, then extraction is the only option left.
  • Infections: Sometimes, the extent of an infection is such that a root canal cannot successfully resolve it.
  • Cost considerations: While usually less expensive upfront, extractions often result in added procedures, such as implants or dentures down the line.

Root Canal versus Tooth Extraction: What’s the Difference?

The root canal and the tooth extraction differ basically in the aspect of tooth salvage. It preserves the structure of your natural tooth in a root canal, while it is wholly removed in an extraction. Both offer some advantages and disadvantages, but your choice must be directed according to the extent of the damage, tooth condition, and general dental health.

Dr. Bhagat’s Recommendation

Dr. Bhagat recommends a root canal in Chicago as it is usually the best option to save the tooth and maintain your natural smile. This way, you can avoid all of the problems associated with tooth loss, such as shifting teeth or expensive replacements later on. 

However, when the structure of the tooth is too compromised or the infection has reached a point beyond repair, there is little choice but to extract the tooth. Following extraction, Dr. Bhagat often recommends considering dental implant or bridge options to fill the gap and complete your smile for smooth functions.

FAQs

1. Can a root canal fail?
Yes, while root canals have a high success rate, they can fail in rare cases if the infection returns or if the tooth becomes reinfected. In some cases, re-treatment or extraction may be necessary.

2. How long does it take to recover from a root canal?
Recovery from a root canal typically takes a few days. Most people experience mild discomfort or swelling for a short time, but this should subside within a week. You can usually resume normal activities soon after.

3. What happens if I don’t replace a missing tooth after extraction?
Not replacing a missing tooth can lead to issues like shifting teeth, difficulty chewing, and bone loss in the jaw. It’s important to explore options like implants or bridges to restore your smile and functionality.

4. Is a root canal more expensive than a tooth extraction?
Root canal procedures can be more expensive upfront due to the cost of treatment and the necessary restoration with a crown. However, extraction may require further procedures, like implants or dentures, which can add to the long-term cost.

5. Can I get a root canal on any tooth?
Root canals can be performed on most teeth, but the success rate may vary depending on the location and condition of the tooth. Teeth with extensive decay or damage may not be good candidates for root canal treatment.